The Battle for New York: City at the Heart of the American Revolution

by Barnet Schecter

Published by Walker & Company

394 pages, 2002







Living History

Reviewed by Paul McLeary


For a place that supposedly shrugs off its past to make way for a perpetually unfolding future, New York City can sometimes barely conceal its ghosts. From the African burial grounds that are occasionally dug up downtown to the winding streets of the financial district, there's a rich history there that New Yorkers just don't seem that interested in. It is precisely this somewhat willful ignorance that makes The Battle for New York such a fascinating read.

The pivotal role New York played in the Revolutionary War is often overlooked and, in particular, so is the Battle of Brooklyn. The disorganized, drawn-out fight (which was called the Battle of Long Island at the time) was the first major engagement ever conducted by an organized American army -- Lexington and Bunker Hill were little more than militia skirmishes -- and the largest battle of the entire war. It was also a barely averted disaster in which Washington's troops were outmaneuvered and trapped although, through some luck and cunning, they did manage to escape to Manhattan before the rout was complete.

When the Revolution broke out in 1775, New York was a city of 4000 wood and brick buildings hugging the southern tip of Manhattan. It had an excellent port and, as the mid-way point between New England and the South, both the British and the rebels felt that it was, as Washington said, "a post of infinite importance." The city was so pivotal to British plans that they left a disproportionate number of troops garrisoned here for the duration of the war, allowing the American Army to move throughout the other colonies with greater ease.

Beginning with the tribal politics of pre-Revolutionary New York, in which the DeLancey, Montresor and Livingston families vied for power, author Schecter paints a portrait of a city we might recognize -- a bustling urban center broiling with religious, political and racial tension, rife with crime, prostitution and radical political ideas; all of which were brought to a head by the outbreak of hostilities in 1775.

As for the Battle of Brooklyn, it started as a chance encounter between some (possibly drunk) American sentries and British and Hessian troops in a watermelon patch near today's 5th Avenue and 36th street, and quickly developed into a major engagement consisting of some 30,000 troops covering the whole of Brooklyn. After the initial encounter, the Americans fell back to the wooded hills of what is now Prospect Park, fighting a pitched battle at the Stone House on today's 5th Avenue and 3rd street in Park Slope with a few thousand British and Hessian troops as they tried to make their way back to the American fortifications at Brooklyn Heights, Fort Greene and Cobble Hill.

With the Americans disorganized and in full retreat, the British missed a perfect opportunity to finish them off when their commander, General Howe, refused to order his men to assault the forts, thinking time was on his side. With about 20,000 men under his command in Brooklyn, as compared to the Americans' eight to 10,000, in retrospect it seems to have been an obviously foolish move. Nor would it be the first time Howe would refuse to capitalize on an opportunity to finish the Americans off during the war, much to the shock of his subordinates and the American commanders.

Still, stuck between the powerful British fleet ready to sail up the East River and the large British Army just outside the walls of the encampent, it looked like the end for the Revolution. It probably would have been if not for what Schecter calls "one of the greatest moments in the annals of warfare."

On August 29th, with the Americans trapped and running low on food and ammunition, a storm blew in from the north, keeping the British from sailing up the East River and completing the encirclement. Taking advantage of the situation, Washington gathered up as many small boats as he could and -- beginning at 8pm and ending sometime around dawn -- started moving his army across the river and into the still unoccupied city without tipping his hat to the British, thus saving his army and -- in the process -- the hope for an independent Republic.

What Schecter does so well is to marry stories like this one with diary entries and letters written by citizens, soldiers, officers and generals in the middle of the action, giving a gripping first-hand account of life on the front lines on both sides of the conflict. In particular, he uses the words of teenage rebel solider Joseph Martin throughout the book, as when he fled the British invasion of Manhattan at Kip's Bay:

Every man that I saw was endeavoring by all sober means to escape from death or captivity, which at that period of the was certain death. The men were confused, being without officers to command them. I do not recollect of seeing a commissioned officer from the time I left the lines on the banks of East River in the morning until I met with one gentlemanly one in the evening. How could the men fight without officers?

Schecter also manages to draw Walt Whitman into the narrative, relating how as a boy in the 1820s Whitman would find the bones of some of the 11,000 American soldiers who died on British prison ships in New York Harbor washed up on the Brooklyn shore and how this led him and others to plead for some sort of memorial to the fallen, the kind which now stand in Prospect Park and Greenwood cemetery.

Another high point is the author's retelling of the British "invasion" of Manhattan two weeks after the Americans' escape from Brooklyn, and the chase from today's Financial District up the east side and into Harlem, where the Americans made a stand on today's 125th street and Broadway, winning their first pitched battle of the war before falling back to the relative safety of Westchester to wait out the winter. Schecter also does an outstanding job of giving the reader an idea of contemporary landmarks, like the line of forts Washington had stretched out across much of today's Grand Street and the British landing at what is currently East 34th street.

The detail Schecter goes into while constructing his narrative is never anything less than riveting, particularly in describing the fuzzy political situation in New York during the war. Once the rebels were driven out, the city became a refuge for loyalists from New England who suppressed rebel sympathizers in a brutal fashion, even refusing to rebuild much of the west side after it was destroyed by one of the frequent suspicious fires, forcing hundreds to live out the war homeless and hungry in what became known as "canvas town."

To Schecter's credit, the book never falls into the soporific trap to which many historians are prone, as they excessively quote documents or get bogged down in extraneous detail. What the author offers is not a textbook account of the war, but an intensely personal tale of the sacrifices made by common men and women who lost as much as they gained in fighting for what looked, on more than one occasion, to be a losing cause. The writing throughout is crisp, concise, and evocative of historical context, with an eye to the modern reader who has some knowledge of New York's not-so-distant past. | January 2003


Paul McLeary has written for New York Observer, Mental Floss magazine and He lives in Brooklyn, New York.